« How to Drink Coffee In Space | Main | Serious Christmas Lights »

The Law of Unintended Web-Site Use

The news that Ning is discontinuing support for adult oriented social networks got me thinking. There's an old economics axiom called the law of unintended consequences that says that "actions of people---and especially of government---always have effects that are unanticipated or unintended."

I think web-site's are the same way. You build a site intending for it to solve one problem, but once users get their hands on it, you find out its good for something else. The question is do you embrace that usage or shut it down. Here's a couple of examples:

* Craig's list - sure everybody's favorite lovable free classified site is a great way to get a job, find an apartment or join a band. Funnily enough, it turns out most people use it for the "erotic services" section. Intentional? Who knows. But the edgy content and the SEO-able nature of that section has proven an effective way for them to boot up local cities. Think the local newspapers websites in these towns would follow this strategy? Ha! And you know how well their sites are doing....

* Google - sure organizing the world's information and making it accessible is a lofty goal, but in reality, lots of the information being accessed is not so lofty. According to these stats, over 7% of the search query stream is actually porn. 7% may not sound like a lot but it's the 4th highest category and the top category is "other." Gee, I wonder why they have image and video search...?

* Facebook - it turns out that despite all the talk about the social graph, Mark Zuckerberg, etc., one of Facebook's biggest draws is that it's a photo sharing site. The killer app is that bit where you tag the individuals in each picture. The people I know who spend hours on that site spend most of that time looking at tagged photos.

* Pownce - yesterday's big news was that would be Twitter competitor Pownce was shutting down. Valleywag had this little nugget in its write-up: "Pownce allowed users to send each other short messages and, most importantly, share files; bootlegging MP3s was a popular if unacknowledged use."

None of these sites made these particular usages part of their core messaging, but they otherwise have have embraced them. Obviously, Pownce didn't end up succeeding - but that's probably for a host of reasons. Maybe they should've promoted the file-sharing bit more....couldn't have turned out worse.

As for the others, they certainly have done well. Probably one of the reasons is that they listened to their users. And by listen, I mean watch their usage.

Anyway, back to Ning. So your customers want to use your service as a place to create adult social networks? That use doesn't work for you? Fine. That may be the right decision for them. But as Chris notes, it's probably not the best way to treat your customers. And any company should be really careful cutting off legal uses of a product, just because they're not what was intended.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Comments (1)


Gina Bianchini CEO of ning,
What you have done is simply bad business. Very bad business! I see class action Lawyers all over you in your future.

Not all Adult sites are bad some are community and or educational based and do much more good than harm. Gina, you should know that I pay you - yes I'm a paying ning client, but I'm being treated like the freeloaders porn sites using ning!

Gina, why are you selling out? Yes I agree, please do remove all the dirty xxx "pure" porn crap that are using your free services, but leave the well intentioned Adult sites alone, especially the ones that are paying you and not breaking laws. I never received a complaint about copyright or anything else.

How are you taking down the sites? At the very least have a human (and not a right wing fanatic) review the sites before pulling them. This is not the job for a scripted robot. (as your tech support informed me). You know, your tech support was useless and robotic. No effort was made to reach my concern... "that's the policy"... brainless customer support. And they refused to review my site and okay it. They said "if it's porn it's gone" You should look into that Gina.

Also one last question... are you planing to reimburse your paying clients when you kick them off your network? Money doesn't grow on trees, but class action law suites are always a possibility... I've already received my first email from the acting lawyer.

You should reconsider, but if you don't - good luck to you, it will cost you tens of millions...

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on December 2, 2008 11:05 AM.

The previous post in this blog was How to Drink Coffee In Space.

The next post in this blog is Serious Christmas Lights.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by
Movable Type 3.33